little white truths

In the below shot I've put it on both eyes and also used it as a concealer. You can tell the slight difference from the shot above - in the above photo my under-eye bags are more pronounced. Note that the upper lash line has already transferred a bit (I talk more about this below).


Verdict

While I do really like this pencil, its lasting power isn't good - at least on me. I have puffy eyes and it transfers in two seconds flat.

Although you can set it with a powder and/or use a primer, it still does tend to move on the upper lash line (and the waterline, if that's where you're intending to use it).

In terms of staying power, it fares much better as an inner corner highlight and as a concealer or highlighter (eg for your browbone), and that's how I'll be using it.

You can also help its lasting power by using a cream shadow on your upper lash line first, and then adding the pencil above it for a stronger colour - so while the lasting power isn't brilliant, you can definitely work with the product.

In sum, I really like this and will definitely use it. Most eyeliners transfer on me as it is, so I'm used to working around that issue anyway. But if you're used to eyeliners staying put, this one might annoy you.

Obviously I'm happy with this inclusion in January's box, since I went and scored myself a second one!

Let me know your thoughts if you've used this pencil. I'd be interested in hearing from anyone who doesn't have puffy eyes like mine - does the pencil last well on you?